DFKI Research Report-91-12



Language: English

by J. Mark Gawron, John Nerbonne, Stanley Peters

The Absorption Principle and E-Type Anaphora

33 Pages


The Absorption Principle is a principle of situation theory which restricts the kinds of parametric information which is available. In particular it rules out abstraction over variable occurrences in paramtetric restrictions (unless the parameter itself is included). In Anaphora and Quantification in Situation Semantics, Gawron and Peters showed that the Absorption Principle has intuitively correct consequences in applications to quantificational and anaphoric semantics, but Sem, Saebo, Verne and Vestre (1990) point out cases of incorrect consequences. The present paper provides an analysis of the problematic cases in which the Absorption Principle is maintained. A key part of the analysis is the postulation that anaphors may have quantified NPs as antecedents, a position which has been vigorously advocated by Evans (1980). As a consequence, anaphors of this type are called `E-Type'. We argue that the pronoun `it' in the following discourse must be analyzed as E-Type:

Tom has exactly one car. It is red.
We provide an analysis of E-Type anaphora with the following properties: (i) the type of the anaphor is derived from the conservative scope of its antecedent; (ii) its semantics is provided by a choice function; and (iii) there is a pragmatic condition that the choice function not be controlled either by speaker or hearer in the discourse. We demonstrate how this accounts for a wide range of facts, including apparently varying quantificational force.

This document is available as PDF-File(23,6MB).

The next abstract is here, and the previous abstract is here.

DFKI-Bibliothek (bib@dfki.uni-kl.de)

Note: This page was written to look best with CSS stylesheet support Level 1 or higher. Since you can see this, your browser obviously doesn't support CSS, or you have turned it off. We highly recommend you use a browser that supports and uses CSS, and review this page once you do. However, don't fear, we've tried to write this page to still work and be readable without CSS.